Law firms at year end: taking urgent enquiries in chat and handing them over
Enquiries under time pressure arrive at year end: how a law firm chat asks about urgency, is not meant to assess any deadline and hands over between the holidays.
In plain language
For many claims, the time limit ends at the end of a year. After that, the other side often does not have to pay. So in December, some people write to a law firm in a hurry.
The chat takes down the request. It asks what it is about, how urgent it is and who is involved. It should not say if a time limit has run out; the firm checks that.
In urgent cases, it hands the chat to a person. It should not promise when someone will call back.
In December, the tone of first enquiries changes in many law firms. Someone who has been waiting for months to be paid for finished work, or who lent money to an acquaintance and never got it back, hears somewhere that something might expire at the end of the year and sends a message late in the evening. The background is in the statute: the regular limitation period begins at the end of the year in which the claim arose and the creditor learned of it or would have learned of it but for gross negligence. For the firm, that is a planning date. For the chat on its website, it is a boundary: whether a deadline is running, when it ends and whether it can still be met is assessed not by the chat but by the qualified lawyer. This article shows how an assistant can still capture such enquiries in full and ask specifically about urgency, while assessing deadlines stays with the firm, and how the handover works between Christmas and New Year, when only a few people are in the office.
Labels in the illustration
- Questions set by the firm
- Area of law
- Contract law
- Matter
- Unpaid invoice for works
- Urgency
- Deadline named, date noted
- Parties
- Other side noted by name
- Contact
- Callback requested, phone
- in the enquiry, not assessed
- Routing per
- handover rule
- urgent or sensitive
- Handover
- to a person
- with history and reason
- otherwise, Pro package
- First consultation
- as an appointment request
- the firm confirms
- December at the firm
- Early December
- Enquiries under time pressure
- Public holidays
- Staffing often thin
- Between the holidays
- On duty in the inbox
- 31 Dec: year end
- Section 199 (1) BGB
- Deadlines are assessed by the firm, not by the chat
- The assistant is instructed to record a date it is given, not to calculate and not to say whether a claim is time-barred
Why December brings enquiries under time pressure
The reason for the time pressure in December is in the German Civil Code. The regular limitation period is three years (Section 195 BGB). When it begins is set out in Section 199 (1) BGB: not on the day an invoice fell due, for example, but at the end of the year in which the claim arose and the creditor knows the relevant circumstances or would have known them without gross negligence. Because the start falls on the end of a year and the duration is measured in whole years, such a period usually also ends when a calendar year runs out. For unpaid amounts under contracts of sale, contracts for work or service contracts, the regular period is the usual starting point. Once it has expired, the debtor is entitled under Section 214 (1) BGB to refuse performance. Special periods, different starting points and the suspension of limitation remain unaffected and belong in the firm's own review.
The regular limitation period begins, unless another start of limitation is provided for, at the end of the year in which 1. the claim arose and 2. the creditor obtains knowledge of the circumstances giving rise to the claim and of the identity of the debtor, or would have obtained such knowledge without gross negligence.
For a law firm, this produces a recurring pattern. People who have let a claim sit for a long time are often only alerted by a remark from friends, a newspaper article or a letter from the other side, and not infrequently with the words year end. The enquiries then arrive in the weeks when holidays, public holidays and year-end work are due anyway, and between Christmas and New Year the office is often only partly staffed. It is this coincidence that makes the first intake delicate: an enquiry that lands in the contact form on the evening of 27 December can sit until the next regular working day if nobody recognises it as urgent. That is not an argument for a chat that assesses deadlines, but for an intake that makes urgency visible and passes it cleanly to a person. How seasonal peaks can be absorbed in general is described in the article on peak season support spikes.
What the assistant captures: sorted, not assessed
What a law firm assistant should do in a first enquiry is summed up briefly on the page about the assistant for law firms: it asks in a structured way for area of law, a short description of the matter, urgency and the parties involved, and the firm receives an enquiry “sorted, but not assessed”. Technically, the built-in enquiry has the fields name, email, phone and matter. What the visitor says about area of law, urgency and parties is meant to be summarised by the assistant in the matter; the conversation history is attached to the enquiry as context. For December, the formula fits exactly. Sorted means: the enquiry names the right area of law and carries everything the lawyer needs to decide for herself how urgent it is. Not assessed means: the assistant is not meant to draw any conclusion from these details, not even a cautious one. It is meant to write neither that the matter looks urgent nor that there is still time.
- Area of law: assignment to the areas the firm has stored, for example contract law or employment law. If a responsibility is missing from the content, the assistant is meant to say so instead of guessing.
- Short description: the matter in the visitor's own words, in a few sentences. No case file and no documents in the chat.
- Urgency: whether a date was mentioned, a letter with a deadline exists or the visitor explicitly calls the matter urgent. The enquiry has no field of its own for this; the answer goes into the matter as it was given.
- Parties: the names of the other side and other parties, so the firm can check for a conflict of interest. The assistant only records the names.
- Contact: name, phone number or email address and, if wanted, a time for the callback. Name, email, phone and matter are the enquiry's own fields and can be marked as required.
Before the conversation becomes an enquiry, the assistant shows in plain words what it contains. The visitor confirms or cancels; without confirmation no enquiry is created. A second click on the same enquiry does not produce a second message in the firm. Under time pressure this is more than a formality: someone who is nervous tends to send twice, and someone who reads a summary is more likely to notice that a date or a name is missing. How intake works in the conversation instead of in a form placed in front of it is described on the page about the lead assistant.
Capturing is not reviewing
The value of the first intake in December lies in its completeness, not in sounding clever. A date the visitor mentioned, written into the matter, helps the lawyer more than any sentence from the assistant about what that date might mean.
Asking specifically about urgency
In many contact forms, urgency is an optional field or missing altogether. In December, this gap weighs particularly heavily. In the chat, the instructions can close it: the firm writes into the assistant's instructions, for example its role, that it asks about urgency in every first enquiry before presenting the enquiry, and puts the answer into the matter. As fixed required details, only the built-in enquiry's own fields can be marked, that is name, email, phone and matter; if one of them is missing, the enquiry is not created and the assistant asks again. A field of its own for urgency is only available with a custom tool in the Custom package or with a form on the firm's website that the assistant fills in after the visitor confirms. For most firms, the instruction is enough. It usually ensures that every enquiry carries a statement on urgency, even if it reads “not stated”, and a full inbox can then be sorted at first glance.
What matters is how the question is worded. “Is your claim time-barred?” or “Is a deadline running out?” ask the visitor for a legal assessment they cannot give, and tempt the assistant to comment on the answer. Questions about facts the visitor knows work better: whether there is a letter that states a date, whether someone has told them by when something has to happen, and whether they have a date in mind themselves and where it comes from. The answer should be recorded as it comes, including “I don't know”. That too is a valid answer. A rule that only accepts a date holds up precisely the people who know least, and they are the ones who need the route to the firm most urgently.
| What the visitor says | What the enquiry records on urgency | What the assistant is not meant to say |
|---|---|---|
| “The reminder letter says 31 December.” | Date given: 31 Dec, source: letter from the other side | whether this date is legally decisive |
| “A friend said it expires at year end.” | Reference to year end, source: third party, no letter | whether the friend's view is correct |
| “The invoice is from 2023.” | No deadline given, invoice year according to visitor 2023 | which year end follows from it |
| “It is urgent, I don't want to miss anything.” | Explicitly called urgent, no date | that nothing will happen anyway |
| “I don't know.” | No statement on a deadline | that there is probably no hurry then |
Wording without a statement on deadlines
The page about the law firm assistant shows the boundary with an example. If someone asks whether an objection is worthwhile and how long they have for it, the assistant replies that it may not assess this, because “prospects of success and deadlines are a legal assessment and stay with the qualified professional”. It then offers to record the date of the letter, propose an appointment and hand the enquiry to the responsible person. The template for law firms excludes statements on deadlines out of the box, and its handover rule instructs the assistant to hand over to the firm for any question about the visitor's own case, deadlines or prospects of success and to point to the first consultation. The following table shows what this looks like in actual wording.
| Question in the chat | Answer with a deadline statement | Answer without a deadline statement |
|---|---|---|
| Is my claim already time-barred? | If the invoice is older, probably yes. | I am not allowed to assess that. I will record your details and pass the enquiry to the responsible lawyer. |
| Is it enough if I get in touch in January? | You still have time until the end of the year. | When action is needed is for the firm to assess. I will note your date in the enquiry and hand it over now. |
| By when do I have to file a lawsuit? | On 31 December at the latest. | I cannot say anything about that. I can hand the enquiry with your date to a person at the firm. |
| What are my chances? | Your prospects are good. | Prospects of success are assessed by the firm in a meeting. Shall I request a first consultation? |
It is striking that the problematic answers in the middle column sound friendly. That is where the risk lies: a reassuring sentence about the time still left reads like information to a tense person, and they act on it. What makes something a legal service is described in Section 2 (1) RDG: any activity in specific matters of others as soon as it requires a legal review of the individual case. A statement on whether a particular claim can still be enforced usually presupposes such a review. It belongs in the hands of the lawyer who reviews the case with the documents, not in a chat that knows only a few sentences from the visitor. The answers in the right-hand column avoid it and still move things forward, because they offer the next step. How such boundaries are phrased in the instructions to the assistant is shown in the article on the system instruction and its boundaries.
When the word limitation comes up
Alongside the instructions to the assistant there is a second, fixed layer. In the system, the lock against legal advice overrides every role, every topic boundary and every handover rule, and it cannot be switched off. It includes a word list for legal topics that contains, among others, the German words for limitation (Verjährung) and prospects of success (Erfolgsaussicht), as well as English terms such as legal advice or lawsuit. If a question contains one of these words, the service appends a fixed notice below the answer: that the assistant is a program, can be wrong and does not replace legal advice. At the same time, it hands the conversation to a person. The answer text itself is still written by the language model; the fixed layer adds to it, it does not rewrite it. Someone who asks in the evening whether limitation is looming for them (“Droht bei mir die Verjährung?”) therefore receives the notice and the route to the firm, and the firm finds the conversation with its full history in its inbox.
The word list is built for clarity, not completeness, and it searches for fixed word stems. “Droht bei mir die Verjährung?” (is limitation looming for me?) hits it, “Ist das schon verjährt?” (is this already time-barred?) does not: the list contains the noun Verjährung, and verjährt is a different word form. Someone who writes “By when do I need to act?” does not hit any word on it either. For such questions the instructions carry the load: the assistant is not to make any statement about which deadline applies in the visitor's case or whether it has been met, and it is to hand over on questions about deadlines. A firm that wants to narrow the gap adds verjährt in the admin area as a word of its own for the legal topic; the list can be extended, not shortened. Taken together, the two layers are no promise that every urgent enquiry will be recognised as such. They are designed so that the chat makes no statement on deadlines, and the instruction to ask about urgency usually still brings it into the enquiry. A deadline that the firm itself names in its content, for submitting documents for instance, is not covered by the fixed lock; the template for law firms initially excludes such statements as well, and whether to change that is a deliberate decision for the firm.
The handover route for urgent cases
For the serious case, the line on the law firm page is brief: “In urgent or sensitive cases it is meant to hand over to a person.” The handover can happen live, by email or, in the Custom package, as a ticket. Before it is triggered, the handover card states the reason in plain words. The conversation then switches to the escalated state, an entry is created and the firm is notified. A later message from the visitor does not pull the conversation back out of the inbox; it stays there until someone takes it over and marks it as done. What makes a good handover in general is covered in the article when the AI assistant should hand over to people.
- One row per handover with title, matter, page, waiting time and responsibility
- The full conversation history, so nobody has to describe their matter twice
- The reason for the handover in plain words, such as a question about deadlines
- The Take over and Mark as done buttons; taking over sets the responsibility, releasing removes it
- A filter by responsibility, so each person sees their own handovers
On the visitor's side, the handover ends with a plain sentence to this effect: the conversation is now with the firm, and a person will get in touch. The assistant is not meant to give a time. It is instructed not to make any commitment that is not in the firm's content, because when someone gets in touch is decided by the firm and not by the product. In December, this restraint matters more than usual. A sentence such as “We will get back to you tomorrow morning” could well be wrong on 23 December, and anyone who relies on it loses exactly the days that mattered to them. One place does make a promise out of the box: the fallback reply that the visitor reads when the assistant cannot answer at that moment ends, in the template for law firms, with “we will be in touch shortly”. It is a fixed text of the firm, not a sentence from the language model, and should be adjusted to the actual availability before December. A firm that knows its availability over the holidays writes it into the knowledge base; the assistant can then state it from that source.
No callback time that nobody keeps
An assistant that promises a quick reply between Christmas and New Year makes a commitment on behalf of the firm. It is therefore meant to state only what is in the firm's content, and otherwise the status: the enquiry has been received, with date, matter and contact details. The same standard applies to the fixed fallback reply.
Between the holidays: staffing and the inbox
The days between Christmas and New Year do not call for new technology, but for an agreement. Who is on duty in which week, who checks the inbox and how often, and where do enquiries go from an area of law whose lawyer is on holiday? In the admin area, each person sets their own on-duty status in the menu, and the inbox can be filtered by responsibility. The on-duty status is information for the team. The visitor does not see it, and the assistant does not derive any promise from it. It shows who is currently available, so that an open handover is not left lying because everyone assumes someone else is dealing with it.
-
Set on-duty status
Before the holidays, agree who looks after the inbox on which days, and set the on-duty status in the menu accordingly.
-
Assign responsibility
Assign handovers from areas of law without cover to a deputy instead of leaving them without a name.
-
Store availability
Write office hours, public holidays and how urgent enquiries are handled into the content, so the assistant states them from the source.
-
Offer a callback request
Visitors who prefer the phone leave a number and a preferred time; after confirmation the request sits in the inbox as an enquiry.
Between Christmas and New Year, a callback request is often a better route than a chat that waits for an answer. The visitor gives a phone number, a preferred time and the matter, sees the summary and confirms it; only then does it sit in the inbox as an enquiry, in every package. The preferred time is a wish, not a commitment, and the assistant should describe it that way. What a callback request should ask beforehand, so the call does not start from scratch, is described in the article on callback requests in chat. In the inbox, what matters most for the person on duty is the waiting time: it is shown in every row and reveals which handover has been open longest.
The first consultation as a request
Not every enquiry in December is urgent. For the others, the usual route is a first consultation. From the Pro package, the assistant offers free times from the firm's appointment types and takes the first consultation as an appointment request; the firm confirms it, and with the confirmation the client receives a confirmation email, if an email address was given. The Start package has no appointment function; there, the route is the enquiry or the callback request. Without a calendar connection, the assistant does not check any external calendar. It calculates free times from the time window, duration, lead time and buffer of the appointment type, minus the appointments already requested or confirmed. Details are on the page about the booking assistant.
For the weeks around the turn of the year, this means that the time windows of the appointment type should match the staffing the firm actually has. A firm that offers no first consultations between Christmas and New Year adjusts the windows beforehand, so that the assistant does not offer times when nobody is there. The routing stays the same as in the drawing above: if an enquiry is urgent or sensitive, it is meant to go to a person and not into appointment planning. An appointment request for mid-January would be the wrong answer for someone whose letter names a date in December, even if it sounds friendly. Combining both means offering the appointment as a second step, after the handover has been triggered.
Set up before December begins
- Set out in the instructions what the assistant asks in every first enquiry: area of law, short description, urgency and parties, with the answer in the matter; mark the matter and the contact fields the firm needs as required details of the enquiry
- Aim the urgency question at facts: letter with a date, date mentioned, explicitly urgent, not stated
- Check the handover rule: questions about deadlines, the visitor's own case and prospects of success go to the firm
- Adjust the template's fallback reply (“we will be in touch shortly”) to the actual availability between Christmas and New Year
- Assign on-duty status and responsibilities for the holidays and agree them within the team
- Write availability between Christmas and New Year and the first consultation process into the knowledge base
- From the Pro package, adjust the time windows of the appointment type to the staffing in December
Before going live, a test run with questions as they are actually asked in December is worthwhile: “Is this already time-barred?”, “Is January still soon enough?”, “What happens if I do nothing?”. In their German wording, none of these three questions hits the fixed word list, so they test the instructions in particular. A set of your own questions runs against the assistant, each with a minimum coverage and a model answer, and the result of the last run is shown at the top of the page. The check is not only whether the assistant refrains from a deadline statement, but also whether it then offers the way forward. After the holidays, conversation analytics, which is part of the Pro package, shows which topics came up and where answers were missing from the knowledge base. Tax firms face a related task at the same turn of the year, covered in the article on client questions about e-invoicing.
What the assistant deliberately does not do
An assistant for the first intake does not replace a person who keeps an eye on deadlines during this period. It does not recognise how serious a matter is; it recognises words and follows instructions. Someone who mentions neither a date nor time pressure lands in the inbox with “not stated”, even if their claim actually expires at year end. That is why intake in the chat does not replace the firm's own review, but makes it faster: the details are ready, the history is attached and nobody has to ask what was meant. How first intake in a law firm is set up in principle is described in the article on the AI assistant for law firms; which tasks the assistant takes on is shown on the page about the law firm assistant.
Frequent questions
May the chat say whether a claim is time-barred?
It is not meant to, and it is set up accordingly. Whether a claim is subject to the regular period, when that period began and whether it was suspended usually requires a legal review of the individual case. The assistant is meant to record a date that is mentioned, but not to say what it means, and to refer the visitor to the firm.
Can urgency be set as a required detail?
Not as a field of its own. As fixed required details, the built-in enquiry only allows name, email, phone and matter to be marked. The firm can, however, instruct the assistant to ask about urgency in every first enquiry; the answer then goes into the matter, even if it is “I don't know”. A field of its own is possible with a custom tool in the Custom package or with a form on the firm's website.
What happens if someone asks about limitation or prospects of success?
If the question contains a word from the fixed list for legal topics, such as Verjährung (limitation) or Erfolgsaussicht (prospects of success), the service appends a notice that the assistant does not replace legal advice and hands the conversation to a person. The list does not catch every wording, not even the word form “verjährt” (time-barred); for the other cases, the assistant is instructed not to make a deadline statement and to hand over.
Does the assistant promise when the firm will get in touch?
It is instructed not to promise a response time that is not in the firm's content, because that is up to the firm. The fixed fallback reply is different: in the template for law firms it says “we will be in touch shortly” and should be adjusted to the actual availability before December. If availability between Christmas and New Year is in the knowledge base, the assistant can state it from that source.
Who sees a handover between Christmas and New Year?
It appears in the inbox of the admin area with matter, waiting time and responsibility, and the firm is notified. Whoever is on duty can take it over or filter the inbox by responsibility. How quickly someone responds usually depends on the staffing the firm plans.
Can the assistant book a first consultation between Christmas and New Year?
From the Pro package, it takes it as an appointment request, with free times from the firm's appointment types; the Start package has no appointment function. The appointment only becomes binding once the firm confirms it. A firm that offers no first consultations during those days adjusts the time windows beforehand.
Ask it yourself, Assistant of this website
Automated assistant