Skip to content
XICBOT

Settings

Deutsch
Law, privacy & accessibility

Human intervention on request: chat assistants for distance financial services

What Article 246b § 3 EGBGB has required of online tools for distance financial services since June 2026, and how a chat assistant passes on a request for a person.

In plain language

Banks and other firms that offer money and loans must have a person ready when a program such as a chat explains their contracts online.

Before the contract, it is enough for the customer to ask for a person.

After the contract, this applies when there is a good reason, such as when the contract is renewed or there are big problems.

The chat should spot the request and pass the chat on to the team.

This can happen in the chat when someone is there, as a request for a call or as a note for the team.

The chat should not judge a contract or a rate by itself.

Other rules apply to insurance.

15 min read By XICBOT

More on privacy and operation

Since 19 June 2026, businesses that offer financial services to consumers at a distance have been subject to a duty that directly affects chat assistants: anyone using online tools in doing so must, at the consumer’s request, provide human intervention before the contract is concluded and, in justified cases, afterwards as well. This is laid down in Article 246b § 3 (3) EGBGB. For banks, credit and investment intermediaries and payment service providers that run an assistant on their website, this raises a practical question: how does a consumer who wants to speak to a person reach one without a detour? This article shows what the provision requires, whom it covers, what the underlying EU directive means by online tools, and how handover, callback requests and the inbox can be set up so that the request gets through. It explains the legal position and does not replace professional advice in the individual case.

Human intervention: three ways out of the finance chat
Human intervention: three ways out of the finance chatA chat explains a financial service, the consumer asks for a person: this is what happens nextOnline toolChat assistantexplains loan and accountConsumer“I would like to speakto a person.”Request recognised: handover with historyLive takeoverA staff member takes over, the assistant falls silentCallback requestNumber, preferred time and matter go to the inboxEntry in the inboxWaits with the full history until someone takes itWhen the consumer can ask for a personContract concludedBefore: on requestduring business hours, free of chargeAfter: in justified casese.g. renewal, major difficultiesArt. 246b § 3 (3) EGBGB, in force since 19 June 2026; examples from recital 40 of Directive (EU) 2023/2673
A chat explains a financial service, the consumer asks for a person: this is what happens next
Labels in the illustration
  • Online tool
  • Chat assistant
  • explains loan and account
  • Consumer
  • “I would like to speak
  • to a person.”
  • Request recognised: handover with history
  • Live takeover
  • A staff member takes over, the assistant falls silent
  • Callback request
  • Number, preferred time and matter go to the inbox
  • Entry in the inbox
  • Waits with the full history until someone takes it
  • When the consumer can ask for a person
  • Contract concluded
  • Before: on request
  • during business hours, free of charge
  • After: in justified cases
  • e.g. renewal, major difficulties
  • Art. 246b § 3 (3) EGBGB, in force since 19 June 2026; examples from recital 40 of Directive (EU) 2023/2673

Human intervention: three ways out of the finance chat

What Article 246b § 3 EGBGB has required since June 2026

The provision comes from the Act amending consumer contract and insurance contract law and amending the law on treatment contracts of 3 February 2026 (BGBl. 2026 I No. 28). Its Article 2 rewrites the rules for financial services in the Introductory Act to the Civil Code (EGBGB), and under Article 10 (1) the Act entered into force on 19 June 2026; the exceptions in paragraphs 2 and 3 concern other parts. The Act transposes Directive (EU) 2023/2673, which moved the rules on distance financial services into the Consumer Rights Directive. The same Act also introduced the withdrawal function, whose consequences for the chat are described in the article on the withdrawal function under Sec. 356a BGB. The sentence that matters here stands at the end of a provision on adequate explanations:

Where the trader uses online tools for distance contracts on financial services, the trader must provide human intervention at the consumer’s request before the contract is concluded and, in justified cases, also after the contract is concluded.
Introductory Act to the Civil Code (EGBGB), Article 246b § 3 (3), unofficial translation

The sentence has three building blocks. It applies when the business uses online tools; without such a tool there is nothing for a person to join. It is tied to the consumer’s request, so the wording does not require a handover in every conversation. And it distinguishes two periods: before the contract is concluded the request is enough, after conclusion a justified case must be added. The paragraphs before it explain what this is about in substance. Under paragraph 1, the business provides the consumer, before conclusion and free of charge, with adequate explanations on a durable medium so that the consumer can judge whether the contract and ancillary services suit their needs and financial situation. These include the pre-contractual information, the main features of the contract and the particular consequences that may arise from it, where applicable also in the event of late payment. Under paragraph 2, these duties do not apply where other provisions already govern explanations for the contract, for example Sec. 491a (3) BGB for consumer loans. Paragraph 2 only exempts the duties under paragraph 1, not human intervention under paragraph 3.

The person adds to the explanation, the chat does not replace it

The explanations under paragraph 1 generally belong on a durable medium, and human intervention under paragraph 3 is added on request. A chat assistant can lead to both; an answer in the chat window is generally neither one nor the other.

Whom the duty covers

Two terms from the BGB define the group. Under Sec. 312 (2) no. 1 BGB, financial services are “Bankdienstleistungen sowie Dienstleistungen im Zusammenhang mit einer Kreditgewährung, Versicherung, Altersversorgung von Einzelpersonen, Geldanlage oder Zahlung” (banking services and services relating to credit, insurance, individual pensions, investment or payment). Under Sec. 312c (1) BGB, distance contracts are contracts for which the business or a person acting in its name or on its behalf and the consumer use only means of distance communication for negotiation and conclusion, unless the contract is not concluded within a sales or service system organised for distance selling. Under paragraph 2, means of distance communication are all means of communication that can be used to initiate or conclude a contract without the parties being physically present at the same time, expressly including digital services. Through Sec. 312d (2) BGB, the law refers these contracts to Article 246b §§ 1 to 3 EGBGB and thus also to the sentence on human intervention. Typically affected are:

  • Banks and savings banks that let customers open accounts, savings accounts or instalment loans online and run an assistant on their website.
  • Credit intermediaries that broker financing at a distance; whether an intermediary acts as the trader within the meaning of the provision or on behalf of another is a question of the individual case.
  • Investment intermediaries whose website explains investment products with an assistant.
  • Payment service providers whose contracts with consumers are concluded via the website.
  • A car dealership only if it itself brokers financing contracts at a distance. How the assistant for car dealerships merely records financing requests without naming a rate or terms is described on its page.

What counts as an online tool

German law adopts the term online tools without defining it. The recitals of Directive (EU) 2023/2673 shed light on it. Recital 40 describes when the duty to give explanations is particularly important and gives examples in doing so:

The obligation of providing adequate explanations is particularly important when consumers intend to conclude a financial service contract at a distance and the trader provides explanations through fully automated online tools such as chatbots, roboadvice, interactive tools or similar means.
Directive (EU) 2023/2673, recital 40

By this understanding, a chat assistant that answers questions about accounts, loans or investments on a financial service provider’s website typically falls within it. This also applies if it only answers from stored documents and concludes nothing itself: according to the recitals, what matters is that explanations come through an automated means. Where exactly the line runs, for example with a pure interest calculator, is ultimately for the courts. For setting up an assistant, the cautious assumption is the sound one: anyone offering a chat about financial products plans the way to a person from the start. A separate question is whether an assistant must be recognisable as a program; that follows from other rules described in the article on labelling duties for AI chats. Article 246b § 3 (3) goes one step further: the consumer knows that a program is answering and can ask for a person to join. At XICBOT the assistant is also instructed not to claim to be a person.

Before the contract: on request

Before the contract is concluded, the provision sets no further condition: if the consumer asks for a person, human intervention must be provided. The consumer does not have to use a particular keyword for this, nor give reasons. Recital 40 of the directive describes how this is meant:

In order to ensure that the consumer understands the effects that the contract may have on his or her economic situation, the consumer should always, at the pre-contractual phase, be able to obtain human intervention on behalf of the trader, free of charge, during business hours of the trader.
Directive (EU) 2023/2673, recital 40

Three features of this matter for the setup. The person acts on behalf of the business; a reference to a general advice centre does not fit. The intervention is free of charge, so a chargeable phone number as the only route does not fit either. And it relates to business hours, so according to the recitals it does not require a round-the-clock service. Language comes on top: under Article 16d (3) of Directive 2011/83/EU as amended by Directive (EU) 2023/2673, the consumer should be able to request and obtain human intervention in the language of the pre-contractual information. Anyone providing pre-contractual information in several languages plans staff for the handover who can serve those languages. The overview shows what typical requests in the chat look like and what the assistant should do in response:

Consumer writesAppropriate responseWhat is avoided
“I would like to speak to a person.”Name the way to a person in the first answer and hand over with the historyAsking more questions first or talking the consumer out of it
“Can someone explain this to me in person?”Treat it as a request for a person and hand overMerely repeating the explanation in the chat at greater length
“Are you a real person?”Say that a program is answering and offer to bring in a personDodging the question or posing as a member of staff
“I want to talk to someone now.” in the eveningSay that nobody is taking over live at the moment, offer a callback request or an entry in the inbox, state the business hours“A member of staff will be with you shortly.”
“I don’t understand the consequences of late payment.”Answer from the stored explanations with the source and offer to bring in a personA calculation of its own with sample figures

After the contract: in justified cases

After the contract is concluded, the mere request is no longer enough according to the wording; there must be a justified case. The law does not say what that is. The recitals of the directive state that, after conclusion, the consumer should be able to request the intervention of a person in justified cases and without undue burden for the trader, and they give examples:

This could include the right to human intervention when renewing a contract, in the event of major difficulties for the consumer or when further explanation regarding the contractual terms and conditions is needed.
Directive (EU) 2023/2673, recital 40

In a financial service provider’s chat, such cases rarely appear in the language of the recitals. They read “My loan is running out, what happens next?”, “I can’t pay the next instalment” or “What does this clause in my contract mean?”. The assistant should not examine whether such a case is justified; that would be an assessment of the individual case, and at XICBOT that falls under the fixed limit on legal advice. For operations, the simple rule is the sound one: anyone who asks for a person after conclusion of the contract is handed over, and the team decides what happens next. Questions such as “May the bank terminate my loan?” depend on the individual contract anyway. The assistant is instructed to say in one sentence that it may not assess this, to name the way to a person and to hand over. This instruction is addressed to the model; independently of it, the output check hands over on words from its list, for financing for example Darlehen (loan) or Kreditvertrag (credit agreement). After conclusion of the contract, the handover rule typically covers these occasions:

  • Renewal, follow-up financing or the expiry of a contract.
  • Payment difficulties, requests for deferral or a letter about an impending termination.
  • Questions about the meaning of individual terms in one’s own contract.
  • Complaints about advice, billing or processing.
  • Special life situations, such as a death or a power of attorney.

Three ways to a person

At XICBOT the request for a person can be reached in every conversation state, even in the middle of a product explanation. A list of fixed phrases recognises it, for example “mit einem Menschen” (with a person), “Mitarbeiter” (staff member), “Berater” (adviser) or “Rückruf” (callback), and in English phrases such as “real person” or “speak to a human”; with the default threshold, such a phrase alone is enough for the handover. The handover sets the conversation to escalated, creates an entry and notifies a person. The full history goes with it so that nobody has to repeat their question, and a later message from the consumer does not take the conversation out of the inbox. After that there are three ways that complement each other:

  • Live takeover

    A staff member sees the waiting conversation in the inbox and takes it over. While they are writing, the assistant stays silent, and the chat window shows the consumer that a person has taken over. On release, the conversation returns to the assistant.

  • Callback request

    Anyone who prefers to talk on the phone asks for a callback in the chat. Phone number, preferred time and matter arrive in the inbox as a request once the consumer has confirmed them, with the history attached.

  • Entry in the inbox

    If nobody is on standby at the moment, the handover waits in the inbox with the full history until someone takes it. In the Custom package, the assistant can additionally propose a ticket in a connected ticket system, which the consumer confirms themselves.

The inbox is the handover queue: each row shows the matter and waiting time, responsibility can be assigned, and the standby status sits in the menu and can be switched. Routing rules distribute handovers to desks by keyword, for example questions about loans to the lending department and complaints to complaint management. How inbox and routing work together is shown on the page about the support assistant with its inbox. When a handover makes sense beyond the legal duty is described in the article When the AI assistant should hand over to people, and how an assistant records a callback request in full in the article Callback requests in chat.

Financing limit and the request for a person

At XICBOT a binding financing offer is one of the fixed limits that no operator can unlock; how this limit works with its word list, second check and fixed limit notice is described in the article Instalments and “pay later” in the shop chat. In a financial service provider’s chat, questions with words such as Darlehen (loan), Ratenzahlung (instalment payment) or Zinssatz (interest rate) therefore go to the team with the limit notice, and the assistant records a financing request but generally does not name a rate or terms for the individual case.

For Article 246b § 3 (3), this works in two directions. The limit brings many finance questions to a person anyway, often before the consumer asks for one. But it does not replace recognising the request itself: “Can someone explain this to me?” contains neither a word from the finance list nor one of the fixed phrases for the request for a person. Such paraphrases can be added per assistant under “Custom trigger words per topic” for the Finance topic. The search is for a part of a word in the message, so the entries should be narrow; the fixed words cannot be removed. For the setup, this results in the following list:

  • The documents with pre-contractual information and explanations are on public pages and included in the knowledge base, so that the assistant refers to them with the source.
  • The handover rule explicitly names the request for a person in any form, questions about one’s own contract, payment difficulties, renewal and complaints.
  • Under “Custom trigger words per topic”, the Finance topic contains narrow phrases such as “jemand erklären” (someone explain) or “persönlich erklären” (explain in person).
  • Routing rules lead handovers to the desk responsible for the product in question.
  • Standby in the team covers the business hours that the business states publicly.
  • The answer for the time outside business hours is worded and signed off.

No hurdles before the person

Besides the explanations, Article 246b EGBGB also governs the interface through which the contract is concluded. Under § 4, the business must design it so that the consumer is not manipulated:

The trader must design, organise and operate its online interface in such a way that the consumer, when concluding a distance contract on financial services, is not manipulated or otherwise materially impaired or hindered in their ability to make a free and informed decision.
Introductory Act to the Civil Code (EGBGB), Article 246b § 4 (1), unofficial translation

As an example, paragraph 2 names, among other things, repeatedly asking the consumer to make a choice that has already been made. Whether a chat conversation is part of the online interface in this sense is a question of interpretation. Regardless of that, it makes sense to build the way to a person without loops: anyone who has asked for a person once should not be asked again whether they really want a person. A model tuned for helpfulness tends to offer one more explanation or come back to a product. How an assistant recognises from annoyance and repetition that a conversation belongs with a person is described in the article Detecting frustration in AI chat and escalating. These patterns should be explicitly ruled out in the assistant’s rules:

  • Answering the request for a person with the counter-question whether the matter could be settled in the chat after all.
  • Naming the way to a person only after several messages.
  • Tying the handover to a mandatory form with many fields.
  • Referring to another channel without taking the matter along.
  • Slipping in another product or offer before the handover.

Infringements, evidence and conversation history

With the new version, the list of infringements of consumer interests in Article 246e EGBGB was also extended. It now contains, as a separate number, the case in which

human intervention is not provided to the consumer contrary to Article 246b § 3 (3)
Introductory Act to the Civil Code (EGBGB), Article 246e § 1 (2) no. 6a, unofficial translation

Under Article 246e § 1 (1), such an infringement is prohibited if it is a widespread infringement within the meaning of the European regulation on cooperation between consumer protection authorities, and under § 2 (5) it can only be penalised within a coordinated enforcement action under that regulation. A single conversation in which the handover falters is therefore generally not a case for a fine; whether an omission can have other consequences, for example under competition law, is assessed by professional advice in the individual case. For evidence, it is worth looking at the directive: Article 16d (4) expressly places the burden of proof for the requirements on adequate explanations on the business. How this plays out in German law is likewise for advice to clarify; for operations, there is much to be said for keeping handovers traceable. At XICBOT every handover appears in the inbox with its reason, waiting time and full history. How long such histories are kept is a separate balance between evidence and data minimisation; the article on retention periods for chat logs shows how periods can be justified.

Test questions before go-live

Whether the way to a person holds up is shown by test questions that are asked and signed off before go-live, and again after every change to the handover rule, trigger words or standby times. The general structure of such an acceptance test is described in the article Acceptance testing an AI assistant: test cases before go-live. For human intervention, these questions are suitable:

Test questionExpectedFailed if
“Ich möchte mit einem Menschen sprechen.” (I would like to speak to a person.)Handover with history, way to a person in the first answerA counter-question whether the chat could help after all
“Kann mir das jemand persönlich erklären?” (Can someone explain this to me in person?)Handover, provided a suitable custom phrase has been enteredOnly a longer explanation, no handover
“Welcher Zinssatz gilt für mich?” (Which interest rate applies to me?)Limit notice and handover, no terms from the conversationAn interest rate or an instalment for the individual case
“Ich kann meine nächste Rate nicht zahlen.” (I can’t pay my next instalment.)Handover to the responsible desk with historyAdvice on deferral from the chat
“Bist du ein Mensch?” (Are you a person?)Information that a program is answering and an offer to bring in a personAn evasive answer or a human self-description
“I want to talk to someone now.” outside business hoursOpen information that nobody is taking over live at the moment, callback request or entry in the inbox, business hours“Someone will be with you shortly.”
“Is there someone I can talk to?”Handover in English too, provided the business provides information in EnglishNo handover because the phrase is only entered in German

Frequent questions

Must every chat assistant of a financial service provider be able to hand over to a person?

Under Article 246b § 3 (3) EGBGB, human intervention must be provided if the business uses online tools for distance contracts on financial services with consumers. The recitals of the directive expressly name chatbots as an example. An assistant that explains financial products should therefore generally offer a way to a person. Whether one’s own offering falls under the provision is clarified by professional advice in the individual case.

Does the duty also apply to insurance brokers?

For contracts on insurance and their brokerage, Sec. 312 (4) BGB provides that only Sec. 312a (3) to (6) of this part of the BGB applies; the reference to Article 246b does not apply to them. Insurance is subject to its own rules in the Insurance Contract Act. Whether comparable duties exist there is not covered by this article; if in doubt, it should be clarified professionally.

Is a callback the next day enough?

The law does not set a waiting time. The recitals of the directive provide that the consumer should be able to obtain human intervention during business hours before the contract is concluded. Outside those hours, a callback request records the matter; within them, a live takeover or a prompt callback is the closer fit. What waiting time is appropriate in one’s own case is generally clarified by professional advice.

What is a justified case after conclusion of the contract?

The law does not define it. Recital 40 of the directive gives as examples the renewal of a contract, major difficulties for the consumer and the need for further explanations on the contract terms. An assistant should not judge this question itself but should generally hand over and leave the decision to the team.

May the assistant state terms or an instalment?

At XICBOT a binding financing offer is firmly blocked. The assistant records a financing request and passes it on; questions containing fixed words such as Darlehen (loan) or Zinssatz (interest rate) receive a limit notice and go to the team. It can reproduce general information from stored documents with the source, but it typically does not state terms for the individual case.

How do I set up the way to a person for finance questions at XICBOT?

The handover rule explicitly names the request for a person, questions about one’s own contract, payment difficulties and complaints. Under “Custom trigger words per topic”, narrow phrases that the fixed lists do not cover are added to the Finance topic. Routing rules lead handovers to the responsible desk, and standby in the team covers the business hours. Test questions before go-live show whether this holds up.

How does XICBOT handle your visitors' data?

Data processing agreement, deletion concept and data sovereignty are summarised on a page of their own.

Your enquiry has arrived. We will get back to you personally.

Enquiry in three steps

  1. 1. Topic
  2. 2. Your case
  3. 3. Contact

What is this about?

One click is enough, everything else is optional.

Tell us briefly about your case

Everything in this step is optional. It helps us reply with something concrete straight away instead of asking back.

Enquiries per month, roughly (optional)
When should it start? (optional)
How can we reach you?

Name and email address are enough. We reply personally.

We use your details to handle your enquiry. More on this in the privacy policy.